skip to Main Content

Kaikodo Journal V

Among Flora & Fauna

Corresponding to the exhibition held between September 18 and October 11, 1997. 45 early Chinese and Japanese paintings; 45 early Chinese and Korean objects (90 color plates). Preface by Howard Rogers. 396 pages.

Includes the essays:
Richard Barnhart, James Cahill, Maxwell Hearn, Stephen Little, and Charles Mason:
“The Tu Chin Correspondence, 1994-95”
Howard Rogers:
“Second Thoughts on Multiple Recensions”
Joseph P. McDermott:
“The Art of Making a Living in Sixteenth Century China”

Several of the problems faced by all collectors, connoisseurs, and scholars of Chinese painting are illumined if not conclusively solved in a series of letters exchanged among a number of renowned professionals in our field of Asian Art. Richard Barnhart, James Cahill, Maxwell Hearn, Steven Little, and Charles Mason deal with multiple recensions of the same composition in Chinese painting. The letters are not published here in full but were abridged so as to preserve the full context of the sometimes highly-charged arguments. Readers will be struck by the varying conclusions that can be and are drawn from the same basic set of visual facts and this in turn should encourage us all to examine our own beliefs on the relationships obtaining between aesthetic quality, verisimilitude, spontaneous expressiveness, and authenticity.

During the short period of time that has elapsed since our Spring 1997 exhibition, a startling number of other versions of one of the paintings in that show have come to light, making the ideas discussed in the letters of more than passing interest to us. Additional historical material was thus gathered and is presented here after the letters in an essay by Howard Rogers on the range of circumstances in which multiple versions of the same painting could come into being.

Implicit in some of the arguments raised especially in the letters are assumptions about the basic factors that governed artistic production during the middle Ming period. An examination of one of the most important of these, the economic context in which many Suzhou literati lived and worked, is made in an essay by Joseph P. McDermott, Fellow of St. John’s College at Cambridge University. Professor McDermott, who collects as well as studies Chinese painting, notes how changing economic circumstances led to a commercialization of the Suchou literati style, especially in the small-scale format of fans, and suggests how, in the 17th century, Dong Qichang and other Songjiang literati responded to that crisis in values.

Kaikodo Journal XXXIX - Spring 2023 (web)Online only
Kaikodo Journal XXXVIII - Spring 2022 (web)Online only
Kaikodo Journal XXXVII - Spring 2021 (web)Online only
Kaikodo Journal XXXVI - Spring 2020 (web)Online only
Kaikodo Journal XXXV - Spring 2019 (web)Online only
Kaikodo Journal XXXIV - Spring 2018 (web)Online only
Kaikodo Journal XXXIII - Spring 2017 (web)Online only
Kaikodo Journal XXXII - Spring 2016 (web)Online only
Kaikodo Journal XXXI - Spring 2015Available
Kaikodo Journal XXX - Spring 2014Available
Kaikodo Journal XXIX - Spring 2013Available
Kaikodo Journal XXVIII - Spring 2012Available
Kaikodo Journal XXVII - Spring 2011Available
Kaikodo Journal XXVI - Spring 2010available
Kaikodo Journal XXV - Spring 2009Available
Kaikodo Journal XXIV - Spring 2008Available
Kaikodo Journal XXIII - Spring 2007
Spring in Jinling - Spring 2004
Kaikodo Journal XXII - Spring 2002
Kaikodo Journal XXI - Autumn 2001
Kaikodo Journal XX - Autumn 2001Available
Kaikodo Journal XIX - Spring 2001Available
Kaikodo Journal XVIII - November 2000
Kaikodo Journal XVII - Autumn 2000
Kaikodo Journal XVI - May 2000Available
Kaikodo Journal XV - Spring 2000Available
Kaikodo Journal XIV - November 1999Available
Kaikodo Journal XIII - Autumn 1999Available
Kaikodo Journal XII - Autumn 1999
In Two Dimensions - Spring 1999
Kaikodo Journal XI - Spring 1999
Kaikodo Journal X - November 1998Out of Print
Kaikodo Journal IX - Autumn 1998Available
Kaikodo Journal VIII - May 1998Available
Kaikodo Journal VII - Spring 1998Available
Kaikodo Journal VI - October 1997Not Available
Kaikodo Journal V - Autumn 1997
Kaikodo Journal IV - May 1997OUT OF PRINT
Kaikodo Journal III - Spring 1997OUT OF PRINT
Kaikodo Journal II - Autumn 1996OUT OF PRINT
Kaikodo Journal I - Spring 1996OUT OF PRINT
Backward Glances - February 1996
Back To Top